|
"Rest for the Weary" by: Nancy Marie Brown (Research/Penn State,
Vol. 17, no. 2 (June, 1996))
Exercise! we're told. Lift weights! Swim laps! Peddle that bike!
Run those miles. Step to it! It's
the fountain of youth -- or if not, at least the best way we know to stay, or become, the picture of
health.
Or is it? One group of Americans, at least, believes it's more important to get some rest.
African-Americans, according to an exploratory study by epidemiologist Shiriki
Kumanyika and health educator Collins Airhihenbuwa, may consider their lives stressful enough --
and exercising just adds to the stress. "The major point of this paper," says Kumanyika, "is to ask,
not what they are not doing, but what they are doing.
"It seems that some may be trying to balance out activities that may require a certain
amount of rest. It may be that African-Americans, rather than exercising, are doing something else
they feel is health-promoting -- resting."
Kumaniyika and Airhihenbuwa queried 53 urban African-Americans, all from southcentral
Pennsylvania, most earning less than $20,000, and some who were single parents; they met in 10
focus groups organized by age. Since most surveys show that African-Americans spend less of
their leisure time exercising than do White Americans, the researchers asked, Why? No time, no
money, and no safe place to do it were some of the answers. But so was their health. Most said
their daily work involved exercise and they didn't see themselves as needing more. "They said,
Rest is important because you stress your body. You get rest to have more energy,'" Kumanyika
says. "Exercise may be seen as expending energy -- as a stress.
"There is still a cultural perception of laboring in the field,' of trying to get to the point
where you can rest," she notes. "If these attitudes are prevalent, it's going to be hard to get
people to exercise, because some will see rest as a competing activity. Studies of exercise
adherence and the planning of exercise programs don't take into account these kinds of attitudes
about exercise, or alternative activities that people might be doing at the time. This knowledge
will help us design health programs."
Shiriki Kumanyika, Ph.D., M.P.H., is professor of epidemiology and associate director of the
Center for Biostatistics and Epidemiology in the College of Medicine, Milton S. Hershey
Medical Center, 500 University Dr, Box 850, Hershey, PA 17033; 717-531-7547. Collins
Airhihenbuwa, Ph.D., M.P.H., is associate professor and head of the department of health
education in the College of Health and Human Development, 1 White Bldg., University Park, PA
16802; 814-863-0435. The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health. Reported by
Steve Benowitz.
|